It is nothing unusual to see hundreds of customers waiting in queues for globally anticipated products such as the latest iPhone. Recently, however, the Chinese brand HEYTEA (in Chinese: 喜茶xi cha), had convinced clients to line up for more than five hours –– and for quite a different type of product. Indeed, since mid-February, Shanghai’s consumers have developed an abrupt craze for cheese tea (Chinese: 奶盖茶naigaicha), which lead to endless queues before the stores of HEYTEA. Observing the crowds waiting for just a cup of tea, we wonder at how brands in China have managed to create a mania over an everyday product.
The food and beverage industry, including breakfast, leisure beverages, and Chinese snacks face a very high demand. In February 2016, the magazine Finance & Accounting of Chinese Trade Unions (中国工会财会) reported that the F&B industry was regarded as the most profitable one in China in 2016. This phenomenon is due to the fact that breakfast and beverage stores have comparatively low costs and high revenues. In other words, this industry is easily able to recover costs. The average investment cost is between 20 thousand to 100 thousand yuan; the average net profit is between 25%-35%. Thus, investments in food and beverage industry are commonly recoverable between 6-9 months. Moreover, this trend has also been enhanced by Chinese Millennials’ behavior; they tend to eat out instead of cook at home.
In this market, HEYTEA competes not only against regional players such as Regiustea (天御皇茶), Coco (都可茶饮), 85 Degree Bakery Cafe (85度C) and Hey Juice (茶桔便), but also against global brands such as Starbucks (星巴克), The Coffee Bean (香啡缤), or McCaffe (麦咖啡).
The Starbucks-inspired cheese tea brand
Since February 2017, HEYTEA’s buzz in China has changed the brand into a phenomenal food trend. According to Yuwan Hu, senior project manager at Daxue Consulting, HEYTEA’s founder, Yunchen Nie (聂云宸), aspires to forge a Starbucks-style brand in the tea market. Nie was just a 19-year-old with a high school degree when he founded his first business in 2010. His mobile phone business, however, eventually closed because it never turned profitable. Following this business experiment, he went on to launch HEYTEA -formerly named ROYAL TEA (Chinese: 皇茶; pinyin: Huangcha)- in 2011 in his hometown, the city of Jiangmen (江门 ; pinyin : Jiāngmén) in Guangdong province. On February 26 last year, ROYALTEA adopted the new name HEYTEA because the characters in its previous name (皇茶) were too easily counterfeited. Additionally, the name “HEYTEA” (喜茶) may be translated as “happy tea,” denoting a sense of positivity.
Even so, there were still many counterfeit brands that sought to imitate the brand. Thus, HEYTEA’s official website has declared that all former ROYALTEA stores have been converted to HEYTEA stores, and that any remaining stores named ROYALTEA are unrelated to HEYTEA.
With a 100 million yuan investment from co-investors IDG Capital and He Boquan in August 2016, the HEYTEA founder Nie expanded the Guangdong-based brand, which now owns 50 branches across China. Thanks to HEYTEA’s buzz in China, especially in Shanghai and Shenzhen stores, the brand’s turnover has reached, in average, over 1 million yuan per month per store – roughly 2000 cups per day. The highest turnover is realized in a single Shenzen shop, at 1.5 million to 1.7 million yuan per month. So, what made those consumers stand hours in line for a cup of HEYTEA?
All elements of Starbucks’ strategy are visible in the Chinese brand’s marketing mix, suggesting that the 25-year-old founder of HEYTEA was influenced mainly by this foreign brand. Furthermore, HEYTEA’s strategy aimed to incite in consumers a sense that they are privileged. Through the experience of a new product, the brand sought to make customers feel as if they are a part of something big.
Consumers waiting in line for tea outside HEYTEA’s shop near Taikang Road (泰康路). Photo Credit: Daxue Consulting.
A product under high expectations
The latest hit in Shanghai as offered by HEYTEA is a tea with two layers, composed 20 percent of a cream cheese topping (奶盖) and 80 percent of a green or fruit tea (茶) base. The cream layer is sometimes sweet, sometimes salty and sometimes sprinkled with salt. Ingredient-wise, however, the brand adopts a strategy quite different from that of Starbucks’. In spite of HEYTEA’s efforts in ensuring the quality of its milk topping’s ingredients, which it sourced from Mingzhi (明治),a top-quality Chinese dairy producer, the brand uses tea leaves of mid-low quality.
Moreover, according to the results of a blind test conducted in May 2017 by the Tood-tasting Group in Shanghai (魔都食鉴局), which aimed to assess the taste of 19 different tea brands, HEYTEA failed to place in top positions.The brand Yi Dian Dian (一点点) emerged as the test’s leading tea brand. Worse still, HEYTEA was placed among the worst five brands in several rounds of the blind test.
HEYTEA was able to obtain a high rank only in the category of green tea, at third place. Nonetheless, it did not defeat its competitor Yi Dian Dian, which came in first place for the category.
Thus, HEYTEA reworked its menu in efforts to increase the perceived value of its drinks. For example, a product previously named “Cheese and milk green tea” (芝士奶霜绿茶) is now called “Green beauty” (绿妍). Similarly, each of the brand’s products was given a “fancier” new name in place of their more descriptive former names.
Throughout the past six years, HEYTEA had changed its menu 5 times. Source: Jiemian website, (界面).
A price above the market
Regarding its pricing policy, HEYTEA positioned itself as providing high value-added products. Each cup of HEYTEA costs between 11 to 29 yuan, with an average of 25 yuan. In comparison, Yi Dian Dian–– champion of the blind test hosted by Food-tasting Group in Shanghai’s —offers tea at undercut prices ranging from 6 to 18 yuan per cup, with an average price of 14 yuan, according to DazhongDianping (大众点评 ).
An optimized customer experience
China’s middle class has become richer. They are increasingly willing to pay more for brand names, differentiated features, and higher quality. Younger consumers are more curious than their parents. As they have more choices than previous generations have ever seen, they are often willing to try new experiences, technologies, platforms, and foreign brands or products. This observation is especially true for the dinning industry. Consequentially, one of the best ways to emerge above competitors in the food and drink sector is to place emphasis on forging not just a product, but a new experience. This strategy successfully meets Chinese Millennials’ expectations for food. Nie understood this pattern, and in order to create HEYTEA’s buzz in China, he attempted to develop the impression of a new experience surrounding HEYTEA beverages. In stores, employees were instructed to ask the new customers if they knew how to drink the brand’s teas before serving them. According to the brand, its tea is supposed to be drunk in a certain way. Stirring or using a straw, for instance, is not recommended.
To increase the perceived value of its products, HEYTEA has also developed eye-catching packaging. Through a transparent cup, the customer is able to observe two differently coloured layers, sometimes topped by golden leaves. The only thing that is truly new to this product, however, is its adjustable plastic cover. This design allows the consumer to concurrently savour both layers of the tea, thus maximizing the product’s taste. This way of drinking is also recommended by the brand, as it creates a mustache of cream on the consumer’s upper lips. As a result, many consumers are incentivized to share photographs of their experience on social media, adding to the HEYTEA’s buzz in China.
A cup of HEYTEA, with tips on how to drink it. Photo Credit: Daxue Consulting.
As inspired by Starbucks, HEYTEA shops display fancy and refined interiors. Once again, to increase the perceived value of its products, the brand operates from premium locations at the top malls of Chinese cities. In Shanghai, for instance, it opened a store in the bustling Raffles City mall (Chinese: 来福士广场) at People’s Square —one of the city’s most popular tourist hotspots. Through the shop’s location in this mall, HEYTEA had access to a clientele of trendy 30-year-olds who earn good incomes. As a result, the brand was able to reach millenials, their target consumers. This strategy is comparable to that of Starbuck’s. In Shenzhen, HEYTEA employs a similar strategy by locating its store in the MIXC Mall (Chinese : 华润万象城 )—specifically, in a unit right next to a Prada outlet. The customers’ sense that they are waiting in line to access a product comparable to that of Prada’s is another way to increase the product’s perceived value. Currently, HEYTEA has been established in several first-tier cities including Shenzhen (深圳), with 12 stores; Shanghai(上海), with three stores; and Guangzhou (广州), with 10 stores. Most of these stores are located in top-quality malls. Additionally, the brand has 19 stores in the province of Guangdong (广东) and two stores in Guangxi (广西). In Shanghai only, however, did the brand truly experiences
Currently, HEYTEA has been established in several first-tier cities including Shenzhen (深圳), with 12 stores; Shanghai(上海), with three stores; and Guangzhou (广州), with 10 stores. Most of these stores are located in top-quality malls. Additionally, the brand has 19 stores in the province of Guangdong (广东) and two stores in Guangxi (广西).
It was only in Shanghai, however, that the brand managed to attract strikingly long queues. Despite HEYTEA’s popularity in other cities such as Shenzhen or Guangzhou, customers did not have to wait several hours for a cup of tea. The phenomenon of HEYTEA in China may be partially explained by the disparity in the brand’s number of stores in each city. Whereas HEYTEA has set up many stores in Shenzen and Guangzhou, it owns only three stores in Shanghai. This scarcity of shops may have enhanced consumers’ sense of the products’ rarity.This strategy is clearly efficient regarding the concept store “HEYTEA black” (喜茶黑金店). Indeed, since last January the brand has launched a unique concept store in Shenzhen dedicated to black tea. Here, the effect is the same as in Shanghai: it created the feeling of rarity, since this store which is the only one offering cups of black tea in a black and gold design. As a result, customers in Shenzen have been queuing in front of this shop. Other stores in town, although popular, do not require an hour-long line-up for tea.
Four months after the opening of HEYTEA’s concept-store « HEYTEA BLACK » (喜茶黑金店) in January 2017, people are still queuing for long hours to get their tea. Source : Toutiao
Unique promotional campaign targeting Shanghai
As the result of our research on Weibo, we found that HEYTEA’s buzz in China appeared in late February 2017.
Prior to February, there were very few references of HEYTEA on social media, and effectively none on formal media. At the time, it did not take hours to buy a cup of HEYTEA. On February 9, however, a single post about HEYTEA from “The Morpheus”, a food and cosmetics critic with 30,852 followers on Weibo, managed to reach a large number of likes — which was unusual in view of the scant number of likes the critic usually received.
Weibo Post from the cosmetics and food taster “TheMorpheus” on February 9. Source: Weibo
The exceptional post by “TheMorpheus” on February 9 received 5,196 shares, 3,567 comments, and 2,169 likes. These numbers may invoke suspicion, however, as the critic’s post usually attract just 200 likes and 100 shares or comments. TheMorpheus said in the post that “HEYTEA is coming, the story between me and ‘Yi Dian Dian’ is ended.” In this post, the reference to Yi Dian Dian—another famous cheese milk tea brand based in Shanghai —is especially interesting. Indeed, two days later, on February 11, HEYTEA opened a new store in Laifushi Square (来福士广场), also in Shanghai.
The proven efficiency of KOLs in China
After the instant fame of “TheMorpheus”, several of China’s renown KOLs (Online Key Opinion Leaders) began to echo the critic’s opinion of HEYTEA within just a few hours. This increased attention may suggest that HEYTEA had paid to raise awareness of its brand. Through an analysis of the comments, shares, and likes related to the post, we concluded that the company had received help from two groups of online influencers to spread its name and credibility on social media.
A source for credibility: professional food tasters
Firstly, HEYTEA hired professional food tasters to raise the brand’s credibility. In China, promotional campaigning via industry experts is an efficient way to gain credibility, as the public is inclined to trust the legitimacy of experts in assessing the product. Several public accounts on WeChat (微信) that provide food recommendation — many of them based in Shanghai — shared articles regarding HEYTEA. However, this strategy is not without cost. This type of KOLs usually collects a fee ranging between 392 and 4,900 yuan per post on Weibo. For instance, the WeChat account “Chichihuo365” (吃货我最大365), which had also shared an article about HEYTEA, commonly demanded 3,8OO to 1,300 yuan for soft advertisements.
A source for visibility: humorous bloggers
HEYTEA also aimed to spread its message to as many consumers as possible. Although some bloggers well-known for their humorous style may not be experts in the brand’s specific market, their large number of followers make them even more valuable than food experts in increasing a brand’s visibility. This phenomenon is evidenced by the much higher advertisement fees these bloggers collect. The KOL Heya, for instance, who had also taken part in HEYTEA’s buzz in China, likely fetched 300 to 23,184 yuan per post.
The advertisement prices of KOLs vary depending on their followers’ numbers, characteristics and degree of involvement in sharing, commenting and liking posts. The major problem with promotions through KOLs, however, is that they do not provide guarantees regarding the effects of their advertisements.
“M大王叫我来巡山”(English : “The King Asked Me To Patrol The Mountain”), followed by 4.961.342 netizens, is one of the humorous KOLs who commented on “TheMorpheus” post. Translation:”There is a new store opening in Shanghai, wait for me to have a try.” This KOL posts his own customer reviews on Weibo. For each post he makes on behalf of a company, he receives a commission of 23,000 yuan. Source: Weibo.
Bringing bustle to the shop
To the aim of translating the online buzz into real-life business, HEYTEA also employed a less-known but effective method. Although the brand apologized for the hours consumers had to spend in line, many articles have revealed that hiring people to line up in front of a shops is an effective means that has been used to create HEYTEA’s buzz in China. Using wait marketing in China isn’t a new trend. In the January 1999 debut of Starbucks in China, the American brand had been accused of the same practice. Nonetheless, despite part of the queue had been hired to arouse public curiosity, the strategy did eventually attract real consumers to join the queue. As customers share pictures while waiting in line, the queue leads to a snowball effect that brought more and more consumers to join the wait. For this reason, most social media posts regarding HEYTEA at the beginning of the buzz were in fact related to the queue. Additionally, the brand had limited the maximum number of purchases per customer to 2 cups in order to avoid “yellow cattle” (黄牛; pinyin:Huang Niu) re-sales. The term refers to someone who earns money by illegally hoarding and re-selling items on demand at a very high price. Moreover, HEYTEA’s limitation on purchase quota had also become a hot topic, which further contributed to the sense of the brand’s prestige.
Illegal resellers dealing with client next to a HEYTEA shop near Taikang Road (泰康路). They are selling HEYTEA’S products more than twice the price to avoid customers to queue. Credit Photo: DaxueConsulting
As a result, we can see that HEYTEA has used a diverse marketing mix to maximize the perceived value of its products. Indeed, in terms of the tangible products, HEYTEA did not seem to offer a menu much different from its competitors. Despite promises of premium products, ingredients used by HEYTEA cannot be qualified as premium. Additionally, HEYTEA’s self-proclamation as the inventor of cheese tea appears to be false. Siyun Naigai Gongcha (四云奶盖贡茶), another tea brand, has sold cheese milk cap tea in China since 2007. HEYTEA’s first store opened only much later in 2011.
Thanks to its marketing mix, however, HEYTEA has managed to boost the perceived value of its products through intangible features. Firstly, they conveyed to the consumer a sense that they were experiencing something new. Then, the brand supported its high product pricing by located its stores in top-quality malls associated to luxury brands. Even so, -apart from the Shenzen-based concept store- the brand only reached exceptional popularity in Shanghai. Their success in this city is likely a result of the KOL groups’ influence. HEYTEA has obtained credibility and visibility by relaying word of their unique product online. Together, these marketing strategies successfully solidified the brand’s image of merit in the minds of consumers. This strategy succeeded in attracting buyers to line up in front of HEYTEA shops, realizing the online buzz in Shanghai.
HEYTEA, another “web celebrity food”(网红食物) phenomenon
China creates celebrities at high frequency
This phenomenon of “Wanghong Shiwu” (网红食物), literally “web celebrity food”, is derived from the term “Wanghong” (网红), which refers to web celebrities. Wanghongs are defined by a large following and large volume of online attention in the form of comments, sharing, and likes. Additionally, Wanghongs often appear in the “hot topic” section of Weibo. Web celebrity food, however, refers to food brands that garner high public attention through social media and quickly become hot topics through WeChat’s social circles and microblogs. According to Evelyn Chen, project manager at the Daxue Consulting research team, whereas the term “Wanghong” developed around the year 2010, its derivative “Wanghong Shiwu” emerged about just five years ago. In China, it is common for social media “friends” to discuss their purchases with each other even if they may not be familiar in real life. This occurrence incentivized Chinese netizens to share pictures as they shop, which in turn led to trends that created sizable queues in front of stores. While the long wait for a single product may come across as unusual to the foreigner, many Chinese consumers view the practice as a statement of their social status and fancy lifestyle.
HEYTEA’s buzz in China is not the first new-food phenomenon. Some Chinese consumers have become so experienced in handling the queue that they even downloaded applications such as “Linqu”(邻趣), through which they hired someone to stand in line for them at a rate of 0.5 yuan per minute.
A few Chinese restaurant chains, including Gelaoguan Bullfrog Hot Pot (哥老官重庆美蛙鱼头) and Xinghualou Qingtuan (杏花楼青团) –– a shop selling traditional Chinese desserts –– have also experienced the same sudden enthusiasm last year, and have maintained their fame even as the queue faded. Success is not always the case, however, as some brands like Yang Wang Bao Jiao Bu (仰望包角布)–– which produce traditional Chinese cakes –– died as the queue did. Indeed, many brands face decreasing preference after just several months since its heyday. These failures usually result from either the loss of prestige or increased accessibility from the opening of new shops. In this process, consumers come to think more rationally of the brand even as they continue to purchase from it.
HEYTEA: Exchanging six years in the shadow for four months of fame.
Although ROYALTEA had been renamed HEYTEA in February 2016, the brand has remained largely invisible throughout the year following the event. Then, the tide turned on February 11 this year, after the brand received the help of KOLs:
- One week later, HEYTEA-related messages on Weibo boomed and search results for HEYTEA posts written by well-known social media users exceeded five pages. Then, more and more newspapers and social media users began to talk about the brand, creating HEYTEA’s queues.
- One month later, the brand reached maximum fame, and more detailed descriptions and reviews about its products were published. In the meantime, KOLs started to share HEYTEA photographs through their pages.
In the following graph, the popularity of HEYTEA began to increase visibly on February 9, 2017, reaching peak fame on March 30, 2017.
On March 26, 2017, there were 9541 Baidu searches on the keyword“HEYTEA”; the figure experienced a sharp increase to 25,909 on March 30, 2017. Source: From Baidu Index
However, HEYTEA’s buzz in China now experiences decreasing popularity, as indicated by Baidu Index. Titles of news in China showed that the discussion on HEYTEA has evolved greatly since the maximum fame in March:
- When the brand first opened its new shop in Shanghai, the news mainly focused on the waiting time for its products or on the limited purchase quota. On March 30, for instance,Sohu.com (搜狐科技) published an article titled “HEYTEA becomes a new ‘Wanghong’ and can be bought by costumers only upon presentation of their government-issued ID cards,” Referring to the yellow cattle phenomenon.
- Overtime, the focus shifted to the downward trend of HEYTEA’s popularity, as well as assessments on its tangible product quality compared to its competitors. On May 5, the same site published another article “HEYTEA is committing suicide,” which alleged that HEYTEA is maintaining the buzz by hiring people to line up.
As said previously, the firm had raised 100 million yuan. Observing the effort to keep the hype alive, articles speculated that HEYTEA may be meeting difficulties in paying back investors. Moreover, as HEYTEA’s products are neither unique nor difficult to copy, the firm may need to revise the menu often to preserve consumer interest. The brand is not yet dying, however. It may be noted that, despite the negative assessments, numerous consumers are still waiting in line for HEYTEA even after four months into the hype. Nonetheless, as is the case in many sectors, the eruption of a new trend will likely lead to the end of the previous one. This observation is especially common regarding Wanghong Shiwu.
Main picture: Credit Photo: Daxue Consulting.
READ ALSO ABOUT THE COFFEE MARKET IN CHINA